How often do gaps fill?

ES traded back to the prior close the same day on 60% of its opening gaps and NQ on 61%, most of them in the first hour. Measured on every regular session since 2016.

Atlantive research 3 min read

Contract

E-mini S&P 500

  • 60%

    Filled the same day

    2,502 gaps since 2016

  • 40%

    Filled in the first hour

    By 10:30 a.m. ET

  • 28 min

    Median time to fill

    Of the gaps that filled

  • 0.29%

    The median gap

    10.75 points

When gaps fill

Half of ES's fills come within 28 minutes of the open. By 10:30 a.m. ET, 40% of all gaps have filled, out of the 60% that will that day.

Share of ES gaps filled by each time of the regular session: All gaps reaches 60% by the close.

The share of all gaps that have traded back to the prior close by each moment of the session, every size together and each size alone.

By the size of the gap

The smaller the gap, the likelier the fill: 82% of ES gaps under 0.25% filled that day, and 22% of those over 1%.

ES gaps by size
Gap, as a share of priceGaps Filled that day Gaps up Gaps down Median time to fill
Under 0.25%1,10382%80%84%9 minutes
0.25% to 0.5%67355%53%59%51 minutes
0.5% to 1%49933%32%36%1 hr 37 min
Over 1%22722%20%24%2 hr 24 min

Gaps up filled on 58% of days, gaps down on 62%. A gap is measured against the same contract's last price before 4 p.m. ET the session before.

If the gap is still open

An ES gap still open at 10:30 a.m. ET filled by the close on 33% of days, and one still open at noon on 19%.

ES gaps still open during the session
AtStill open Filled later
9:45 a.m.76%47%
10:00 a.m.69%42%
10:30 a.m.60%33%
11:00 a.m.55%27%
12:00 p.m.50%19%
2:00 p.m.45%11%

Of all gaps, the share not yet filled at each time, and of those, the share that filled later that day.

Year by year

ES's same-day fill rate has moved between 51% in 2020 and 65% in 2022.

Share of ES gaps filled the same day, by year. Under each year, the year's median gap.

Under each year, its median gap as a share of price. A year the data ends in is outlined.

What the rate does not say

A gap that fills 60% of the time is not a trade that wins 60% of the time. A fade has a stop, costs and slippage, and a gap that does not fill can run a long way first. The gap fill strategy, backtested shows what the same days came to once a stop and costs are in.

Method and data

Measured from CME Globex 1-second bars in our own archive, the bars the product backtests on.

Source
CME Globex 1-second bars in Atlantive's own archive, the bars the product backtests on. Each session's contract is the most traded one, rolled as the market moved.
Session
The regular session, 9:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. ET, on the futures themselves, not on the cash index.
A gap
The session's first price against the same contract's last price before 4 p.m. the session before. Under one tick is a flat open, counted and left out of the rates.
A fill
Any 1-second bar of the same session that trades back to the prior close.
A range
The high and low of the session's first 5, 15, 30 or 60 minutes. A break is any 1-second bar past it after it ends.
Left out
A contract's first session, whose prior close is another contract's. Sessions the exchange closed early or held in part, and the session after one. On ES, 206 of 2,728 sessions.
What this is not
Not advice and not a forecast. A rate over past sessions says how often something happened, not what the next session will do, and no costs or fills are in it. The archive's last session here is July 31, 2026.

How to cite

Atlantive. “How often do gaps fill?” https://atlantive.ai/blog/how-often-do-gaps-fill. Data: CME Globex 1-second bars, computed November 6, 2026.

gaps-and-opening-ranges.csv One row per contract and session

Trading for a prop firm?
Let our AI find
the best challenge
for your strategy.

It runs your trades through the rules of every account, then tells you which one to buy and what size to trade.

No card needed. Free credits every month.

  • Most money: Blue Guardian Futures Direct 50K, $5,084
  • Best payout odds: Funded Futures Family Straight to Funded 50K, 98%
  • Fastest pass: Phidias Express to Live 50K, 11 days
Blue Guardian Futures Direct 50K
Most money

$5,084

Median net across 2,000 simulated runs

Evaluation
None
First payout
97%
Fees paid
$1,521

Median net across 2,000 simulated runs

Best 5%$13,143Worst 5%−$412
Day 060120180
Example: ES opening range breakout

Gap fill questions

How often do gaps fill?

On index futures, more often than not. From January 2016 to July 2026, ES traded back to the prior close the same day on 60% of its opening gaps, NQ on 61% and YM on 61%; RTY, since 2018, on 63%. Atlantive measured every regular session from CME Globex 1-second bars.

Does the size of a gap change how often it fills?

Yes, by a lot. ES gaps under 0.25% of price filled the same day 82% of the time, 0.25% to 0.5% on 55%, 0.5% to 1% on 33%, and gaps over 1% on 22%. On NQ the same four sizes filled on 85%, 62%, 46% and 25%.

How long does a gap take to fill?

Half of the ES gaps that filled did so within 28 minutes of the 9:30 a.m. ET open, and half of NQ's within 17 minutes. By 10:30 a.m., 40% of all ES gaps and 44% of all NQ gaps had filled.

If a gap has not filled by 10:30 a.m., will it still fill?

Less often. An ES gap still open at 10:30 a.m. ET filled by the close on 33% of days, and one still open at noon on 19%. On NQ the same figures are 30% and 17%.

Do gaps up and gaps down fill equally?

Close to it, with gaps down a little ahead. ES filled 58% of gaps up and 62% of gaps down; NQ filled 60% and 62%.

Is trading gap fills profitable?

A fill rate is not a win rate: a fade has a stop and costs, and a gap that does not fill can run a long way first. Atlantive's backtest of a gap fill strategy from 2016 to 2026 lost $35,570 on ES and made $66,798 on NQ after costs, with one contract.

Test your own gap rule, on the same bars.

May we measure this visit?

With your consent, Google Analytics and PostHog count visits to these pages. You can separately allow Google Ads to measure visits from our ads. Visit measurement starts only after you choose. Cookie policy