
Lucid vs Take Profit Trader
On the funded account, Lucid's drawdown moves only at the day's close; Take Profit Trader's moves with open profit. Lucid costs $163 less to reach funded at 50K.
Lucid and Take Profit Trader side by side
Lucid or Take Profit Trader
for your strategy?
Our AI runs your trades through both firms' rules and every other account's, then tells you which one to buy and what size to trade.
No card needed. Free credits every month.
- Most money: Blue Guardian Futures Direct 50K, $5,084
- Best payout odds: Funded Futures Family Straight to Funded 50K, 98%
- Fastest pass: Phidias Express to Live 50K, 11 days
$5,084
Median net across 2,000 simulated runs
- Evaluation
- None
- First payout
- 97%
- Fees paid
- $1,521
Median net across 2,000 simulated runs
Questions about Lucid and Take Profit Trader
Which is better, Lucid or Take Profit Trader?
That depends on the rules your trading has to live with. Lucid is easier on minimum days, funded drawdown, funded payout buffer, funded news windows and activation fee. Take Profit Trader is easier on where the drawdown stops, consistency, funded days before a payout, funded smallest payout and payout cap. On one real ES strategy, the runs do not call either one.
Is Lucid or Take Profit Trader easier to pass?
On 2,000 simulated runs of one ES strategy, Lucid's LucidFlex 50K passes 41% of the time and Take Profit Trader's Test 50K 40%. The runs do not all agree, so this strategy cannot call it. At both, most failed attempts end on the trailing drawdown.
Which reaches a first payout more often, Lucid or Take Profit Trader?
On 2,000 simulated runs of one ES strategy, Lucid's LucidFlex 50K reaches a first payout within 180 days 87% of the time and Take Profit Trader's Test 50K 80%. The runs do not all agree, so this strategy cannot call it.
Is Lucid or Take Profit Trader cheaper?
Counted at the prices traders usually pay, an attempt costs $434 in fees on average at Lucid and $1,231 at Take Profit Trader. Lucid at 40% off list, $69 (list $115); Take Profit Trader at 40% off list, $102 (list $170). Lucid shows its coupon to every visitor. The activation fee is None at Lucid and $130 at Take Profit Trader. After fees, the median attempt keeps +$1,492 at Lucid and +$578 at Take Profit Trader. The runs do not all agree, so this strategy cannot call it.
What rules differ between Lucid and Take Profit Trader?
On the accounts shown here, these rules differ. Passing the evaluation: drawdown stops trailing, daily loss limit in both stages, consistency and minimum days. Reaching a first payout: drawdown, days before a payout, payout buffer, smallest payout and news windows. Fees and what is kept: evaluation price, activation fee, reset, profit split, payout cap, payout size and most payouts. Automation: automated strategies and trade copiers. Every size and source is on the Lucid Trading rules and Take Profit Trader rules pages.