MACD crossover strategy
On ES futures, the MACD crossover lost $99,518 after costs and ran a $100,000 account down to its margin on November 24, 2017. The run stops there.
TrendIntraday5-minute barsBacktested Nov 6, 2026
MACD crossover backtest, the result
Contract
E-mini S&P 500
-
−$99.5K
Net after costs
After $85,443 in fees and slippage
-
0 of 2
Years that made money
January 2016 to November 2017
-
−$104K
Largest drawdown
Peak to trough, 1 contract
-
−$33
Average trade
3,012 trades
Net after costs by month, January 2016 to November 2017.
MACD crossover rules
Buy when the MACD line crosses above its signal line, and sell when it crosses back below, on 5-minute bars.
A drawing of the rules on a made-up day, not a result.
- The MACD line is EMA(12) - EMA(26) of the five-minute close and the signal line its EMA(9), on every close of the Globex session.
- When the line crosses above the signal the strategy goes long, and when it crosses below it goes short, turning round on the opposite cross.
- New positions are taken only on bars that close in the day session before its exit minute.
- Whatever is open at the exit minute is closed: 15:45 New York on ES (day session 9:30-16:00), 14:30 on CL (day session 9:00-14:30).
- Decides on
- 5-minute bars
- Holds
- Nothing overnight
- Parameters
- warmup 35, open minute 570, exit minute 945, bar minutes 5
Results by year
It made money in 0 of 2 years on ES. Its best year was 2016, −$46,596, and its worst 2016, −$46,596. The account was closed out on November 24, 2017, so the years stop there.
| Year | Net | Trades | Win rate | Drawdown | Buy and hold |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | −$46,596 | 1,554 | 32% | −$50,667 | +$11,497 |
| 2017, Jan to Nov | −$52,922 | 1,458 | 25% | −$53,271 | +$21,936 |
MACD crossover backtest results
On ES it lost $14,075 before costs, then paid $85,443 in fees and slippage.
- Net = before costs − fees − slippage
- ES: −$14,075 − $10,143 − $75,300 = −$99,518
The whole interval is under zero: after costs, the average trade lost money.
MACD crossover code and Pine Script
The strategy as the backtest ran it, and the Pine Script our compiler wrote from it for TradingView.
1from atlantive import BUY, EMA, NEW_YORK, SELL, Bars, Session, Strategy2 3 4class MacdCrossover(Strategy):5 """MACD (12, 26, 9) crossover on five-minute bars, traded in the contract's day session.6 7 The MACD line is EMA(12) - EMA(26) of the five-minute close and the signal line its EMA(9), all8 on every close of the Globex session, alpha 2 / (n + 1). When the line crosses above the signal9 the strategy goes long, and when it crosses below it goes short, turning round on the opposite10 cross. New positions are taken only on bars that close in the day session before its exit11 minute, and whatever is open then is closed: 9:30 to 15:45 New York on the equity index, 9:0012 to 14:30 on crude oil. No cross is read before 35 bars (26 + 9) have closed on the contract.13 """14 15 data = "bars"16 17 class Params:18 warmup: int = 3519 open_minute: int = 57020 exit_minute: int = 94521 bar_minutes: int = 522 clip: int = 123 24 class State:25 clock: Session(zone=NEW_YORK)26 bars: Bars(interval_ns=300_000_000_000)27 fast: EMA(alpha=0.15384615384615385)28 slow: EMA(alpha=0.07407407407407407)29 signal: EMA(alpha=0.2)30 last_diff: float31 seen: int32 33 def on_event(self, view, ev, orders):34 self.clock.update(ev)35 if not self.bars.update(ev):36 return37 minute = self.clock.prev_minute38 close = float(self.bars.prev_close)39 self.fast.update(close)40 self.slow.update(close)41 line = self.fast.value - self.slow.value42 self.signal.update(line)43 diff = line - self.signal.value44 self.seen += 145 ends = minute + self.p.bar_minutes46 in_day = minute >= self.p.open_minute and ends < self.p.exit_minute47 crossed_up = self.seen > self.p.warmup and self.last_diff <= 0 and diff > 048 crossed_down = self.seen > self.p.warmup and self.last_diff >= 0 and diff < 049 self.last_diff = diff50 if view.position != 0 and not in_day:51 if view.position > 0:52 orders.ioc(side=SELL, qty=abs(view.position))53 else:54 orders.ioc(side=BUY, qty=abs(view.position))55 return56 if not in_day:57 return58 if crossed_up:59 if view.position < 0:60 orders.ioc(side=BUY, qty=abs(view.position) + self.p.clip)61 elif view.position == 0:62 orders.ioc(side=BUY, qty=self.p.clip)63 elif crossed_down:64 if view.position > 0:65 orders.ioc(side=SELL, qty=abs(view.position) + self.p.clip)66 elif view.position == 0:67 orders.ioc(side=SELL, qty=self.p.clip) 1//@version=62// MacdCrossover, exported from Atlantive.3// Chart simulation: decisions use completed bars; market orders fill at the next bar open.4// Native fills, fees, data gaps and session boundaries can differ. Re-test on the target symbol.5// Use standard time-based candles and the strategy's timeframe, not synthetic chart prices.6// Pine v6 trims old trade records at its order limit; the strategy keeps calculating.7// Margin is explicitly disabled to retain the native signal simulation's sizing.8strategy("MacdCrossover", overlay=true, initial_capital=100000.0, commission_type=strategy.commission.cash_per_contract, commission_value=1.68, default_qty_type=strategy.fixed, default_qty_value=1, calc_on_every_tick=false, process_orders_on_close=false, slippage=0, margin_long=0, margin_short=0)9 10if timeframe.in_seconds() != 30011 runtime.error("MacdCrossover was exported for the 5 minute timeframe; set the chart to 5.")12 13warmup = input.int(35, "warmup", minval=-9007199254740991, maxval=9007199254740991)14open_minute = input.int(570, "open_minute", minval=-9007199254740991, maxval=9007199254740991)15exit_minute = input.int(945, "exit_minute", minval=-9007199254740991, maxval=9007199254740991)16bar_minutes = input.int(5, "bar_minutes", minval=-9007199254740991, maxval=9007199254740991)17clip = input.int(1, "clip", minval=-9007199254740991, maxval=9007199254740991)18 19_q_safe_int(x) =>20 if math.abs(x) > 900719925474099121 runtime.error("an integer left the exact chart range; this run cannot be compared faithfully")22 int(x)23_q_int(x) => _q_safe_int(x < 0 ? math.ceil(x) : math.floor(x))24_q_iadd(a, b) => _q_safe_int(a + b)25 26_q_close = _q_int(math.round(close * 1000000000.0))27 28var float last_diff = 0.029var int seen = 030// clock: completed chart bar's opening timestamp (America/New_York).31_q_clock_prev_minute = hour(time, "America/New_York") * 60 + minute(time, "America/New_York")32_q_clock_prev_second = _q_clock_prev_minute * 60 + second(time, "America/New_York")33_q_clock_prev_weekday = (dayofweek(time, "America/New_York") + 5) % 734_q_clock_prev_day = int(timestamp("UTC", year(time, "America/New_York"), month(time, "America/New_York"), dayofmonth(time, "America/New_York"), 0, 0) / 86400000)35// Current clock: this chart bar's scheduled close, known without a future bar.36// A native next event after a data gap can carry a later time.37_q_clock_minute = hour(time_close, "America/New_York") * 60 + minute(time_close, "America/New_York")38_q_clock_second = _q_clock_minute * 60 + second(time_close, "America/New_York")39_q_clock_weekday = (dayofweek(time_close, "America/New_York") + 5) % 740_q_clock_day = int(timestamp("UTC", year(time_close, "America/New_York"), month(time_close, "America/New_York"), dayofmonth(time_close, "America/New_York"), 0, 0) / 86400000)41_q_clock_seen = 142var float _q_fast_value = 0.043var bool _q_fast_seeded = false44var int _q_fast_skipped = 045var int _q_fast_frozen = 046var float _q_slow_value = 0.047var bool _q_slow_seeded = false48var int _q_slow_skipped = 049var int _q_slow_frozen = 050var float _q_signal_value = 0.051var bool _q_signal_seeded = false52var int _q_signal_skipped = 053var int _q_signal_frozen = 054int minute_l = na55float close_l = na56float line_l = na57float diff = na58int ends = na59bool in_day = false60bool crossed_up = false61bool crossed_down = false62 63bool _q_running = true64minute_l := _q_int(_q_clock_prev_minute)65close_l := _q_close * 1.066_q_sample1 = close_l67if na(_q_sample1) or math.abs(_q_sample1) > 1.7976931348623157e30868 _q_fast_skipped := _q_fast_skipped + 169else70 if not _q_fast_seeded71 _q_fast_value := _q_sample172 _q_fast_seeded := true73 else74 _q_moved2 = _q_fast_value + 0.15384615384615385 * (_q_sample1 - _q_fast_value)75 if _q_moved2 == _q_fast_value and _q_sample1 != _q_fast_value76 _q_fast_frozen := _q_fast_frozen + 177 _q_fast_value := _q_moved278_q_sample3 = close_l79if na(_q_sample3) or math.abs(_q_sample3) > 1.7976931348623157e30880 _q_slow_skipped := _q_slow_skipped + 181else82 if not _q_slow_seeded83 _q_slow_value := _q_sample384 _q_slow_seeded := true85 else86 _q_moved4 = _q_slow_value + 0.07407407407407407 * (_q_sample3 - _q_slow_value)87 if _q_moved4 == _q_slow_value and _q_sample3 != _q_slow_value88 _q_slow_frozen := _q_slow_frozen + 189 _q_slow_value := _q_moved490line_l := _q_fast_value - _q_slow_value91_q_sample5 = line_l92if na(_q_sample5) or math.abs(_q_sample5) > 1.7976931348623157e30893 _q_signal_skipped := _q_signal_skipped + 194else95 if not _q_signal_seeded96 _q_signal_value := _q_sample597 _q_signal_seeded := true98 else99 _q_moved6 = _q_signal_value + 0.2 * (_q_sample5 - _q_signal_value)100 if _q_moved6 == _q_signal_value and _q_sample5 != _q_signal_value101 _q_signal_frozen := _q_signal_frozen + 1102 _q_signal_value := _q_moved6103diff := line_l - _q_signal_value104seen := _q_int(_q_iadd(seen, 1))105ends := _q_int(_q_iadd(minute_l, bar_minutes))106in_day := minute_l >= open_minute and ends < exit_minute107crossed_up := seen > warmup and last_diff <= 0 and diff > 0108crossed_down := seen > warmup and last_diff >= 0 and diff < 0109last_diff := diff110if _q_int(strategy.position_size) != 0 and not in_day111 if _q_int(strategy.position_size) > 0112 _q_qty7 = _q_int(math.abs(_q_int(strategy.position_size)))113 if _q_qty7 <= 0114 runtime.error("market order quantity must be a positive whole unit")115 _q_pos7 = _q_int(strategy.position_size)116 if _q_pos7 < 0 or _q_pos7 > 0 and _q_qty7 < _q_pos7117 runtime.error("this order would add to or partially reduce a position, so its trade ledger would not be faithful")118 strategy.order("q1", strategy.short, _q_qty7)119 else120 _q_qty8 = _q_int(math.abs(_q_int(strategy.position_size)))121 if _q_qty8 <= 0122 runtime.error("market order quantity must be a positive whole unit")123 _q_pos8 = _q_int(strategy.position_size)124 if _q_pos8 > 0 or _q_pos8 < 0 and _q_qty8 < -_q_pos8125 runtime.error("this order would add to or partially reduce a position, so its trade ledger would not be faithful")126 strategy.order("q2", strategy.long, _q_qty8)127 _q_running := false128if _q_running129 if not (in_day)130 _q_running := false131if _q_running132 if crossed_up133 if _q_int(strategy.position_size) < 0134 _q_qty9 = _q_int(_q_iadd(math.abs(_q_int(strategy.position_size)), clip))135 if _q_qty9 <= 0136 runtime.error("market order quantity must be a positive whole unit")137 _q_pos9 = _q_int(strategy.position_size)138 if _q_pos9 > 0 or _q_pos9 < 0 and _q_qty9 < -_q_pos9139 runtime.error("this order would add to or partially reduce a position, so its trade ledger would not be faithful")140 strategy.order("q3", strategy.long, _q_qty9)141 else if _q_int(strategy.position_size) == 0142 _q_qty10 = _q_int(clip)143 if _q_qty10 <= 0144 runtime.error("market order quantity must be a positive whole unit")145 _q_pos10 = _q_int(strategy.position_size)146 if _q_pos10 > 0 or _q_pos10 < 0 and _q_qty10 < -_q_pos10147 runtime.error("this order would add to or partially reduce a position, so its trade ledger would not be faithful")148 strategy.order("q4", strategy.long, _q_qty10)149 else if crossed_down150 if _q_int(strategy.position_size) > 0151 _q_qty11 = _q_int(_q_iadd(math.abs(_q_int(strategy.position_size)), clip))152 if _q_qty11 <= 0153 runtime.error("market order quantity must be a positive whole unit")154 _q_pos11 = _q_int(strategy.position_size)155 if _q_pos11 < 0 or _q_pos11 > 0 and _q_qty11 < _q_pos11156 runtime.error("this order would add to or partially reduce a position, so its trade ledger would not be faithful")157 strategy.order("q5", strategy.short, _q_qty11)158 else if _q_int(strategy.position_size) == 0159 _q_qty12 = _q_int(clip)160 if _q_qty12 <= 0161 runtime.error("market order quantity must be a positive whole unit")162 _q_pos12 = _q_int(strategy.position_size)163 if _q_pos12 < 0 or _q_pos12 > 0 and _q_qty12 < _q_pos12164 runtime.error("this order would add to or partially reduce a position, so its trade ledger would not be faithful")165 strategy.order("q6", strategy.short, _q_qty12) How it was tested
The published rules, never tuned on the data, with real costs on every fill. Every strategy here is tested the same way.
- Market data
- CME Globex 5-minute bars, Jan 2, 2016 to Jul 31, 2026
- Rules
- As published, with the published parameters, never tuned on this data
- Size
- 1 contract on every trade
- Contract
- The most traded one, rolled as the market moved
- Fees
- The broker's $0.50 a side, plus CME's and the NFA's fees when the window opens
- Slippage
- 1 tick a side on ES, 2 in NQ's regular session and 3 outside it, 1 on other markets, where it was not measured
- Stops and entries
- Tested on 1-second closes and filled at the next bar
- Contracts traded
- ES: 43 contracts, ESH6 to ESU6CL: 128 contracts, CLG6 to CLU6
- Costs paid
- ES: $10,143 in fees, $75,300 in slippageCL: $14,301 in fees, $71,780 in slippage
- Warm-up
- None: each contract reads only its own bars
- Flagged days
- ES: NoneCL: None Days the data holds too few bars for. Flagged, not removed.
Could you pass
a prop firm challenge
with the MACD crossover?
A backtest says whether a strategy makes money. Our AI runs its trades through the rules of every prop firm account, then tells you which one it would pass and at what size.
No card needed. Free credits every month.
- Most money: Blue Guardian Futures Direct 50K, $5,084
- Best payout odds: Funded Futures Family Straight to Funded 50K, 98%
- Fastest pass: Phidias Express to Live 50K, 11 days
$5,084
Median net across 2,000 simulated runs
- Evaluation
- None
- First payout
- 97%
- Fees paid
- $1,521
Median net across 2,000 simulated runs
Questions about the MACD crossover
What is the MACD crossover?
Buy when the MACD line crosses above its signal line, and sell when it crosses back below, on 5-minute bars. The rules follow Gerald Appel, The Moving Average Convergence-Divergence Trading Method (1979). Atlantive backtested it on CME futures from January 2016 to July 2026 after costs.
Is the MACD crossover profitable on ES futures?
Not in this backtest: on ES futures from January 2016 to November 2017 it lost $99,518 after costs, over 3,012 trades, positive in 0 of 2 years; on CL it lost $99,021. Buying and holding one ES contract over the same window made $236,212. The average trade was −$33, its 95% interval −$40 to −$26. These are hypothetical results of a backtest, not of trading.
What are the MACD crossover's rules?
The MACD line is EMA(12) - EMA(26) of the five-minute close and the signal line its EMA(9), on every close of the Globex session. When the line crosses above the signal the strategy goes long, and when it crosses below it goes short, turning round on the opposite cross. New positions are taken only on bars that close in the day session before its exit minute. Whatever is open at the exit minute is closed: 15:45 New York on ES (day session 9:30-16:00), 14:30 on CL (day session 9:00-14:30). The rules follow Gerald Appel, The Moving Average Convergence-Divergence Trading Method (1979). Its parameters are the published ones, never tuned on the data it was tested on.
How was the MACD crossover backtested?
On CME Globex data from January 2016 to July 2026, one contract, on 5-minute bars, rolled to the most traded contract as the market moved, with the broker's and CME's fees and the slippage measured on each market. Stops and entries were tested on 1-second closes and filled at the next bar. Nothing was fitted to the data.
Can I run the MACD crossover in TradingView?
Yes. The page carries its Pine Script, written by Atlantive's compiler from the same code the backtest ran, for TradingView's strategy tester. A chart's fills and fees can differ from the backtest's, so test it again on the symbol you trade.
Can I change the MACD crossover and test it again?
Yes. Rerun it in Atlantive: a new chat opens with the strategy's rules in the box, for you to read, change and send. The agent writes the code, backtests it on the market and window you name, and reports the result with its costs.